The frenzy that has characterized the Vancouver real estate market since

2004 had the owners of this house believing their property would sell in

days. It hasn't. And now some are saying the air is leaking out of an

overinflated market


Nov 13, 2006

VANCOUVER -- When Stephen Webber and his wife put their Vancouver-area

townhouse up for sale in September, they expected to close a deal within a month.

After several open houses, nearly a dozen private showings and two price cuts, they're

still waiting.

"We have been surprised by the lack of activity," Mr. Webber says. "It seems there is a

lot of supply out there. Buyers have more choices. There is not that rush. And there might

be hesitation because of what's going on in the States."

If buyers are not rushing, it may be because they don't have to. The frenzy that

characterized the Vancouver housing market since 2004 is disappearing, replaced by one

in which buyers have more than mere hours to make a decision. Instead of multiple

offers, bidding wars and homes being snapped up virtually overnight, the current market

is characterized by growing number of listings, a slower rate of price increases and even

price cuts.

Nobody is talking about a crash. Limited land supply, population growth, the 2010

Winter Olympics and a strong regional economy all point to long-term healthy housing

demand. But there is a sense the air is leaking out of what had become an overinflated


"On the Labour Day weekend, I sold a house in Shaughnessy for $300,000 over listing

[price] with 10 offers," Macdonald Realtors agent Lorne Goldman says.

"Those days are becoming less frequent."

Some sellers are having to reduce their asking price, Mr. Goldman says, especially if

they're fixated on the spectacular returns that defined this market for the past couple of


"Up until a month or so ago, most product would sell relatively quickly, in a week or

two," says Marty Pospischil of Dexter Associates Realty. "Now it's not uncommon to

have something listed for a month or longer."

Over the past two months, 15 per cent of sellers have reduced the price of their homes in

order to spur a sale, compared with roughly 2 per cent of sellers earlier in the year, says

Vic Jang of Sutton West Coast Realty. But the biggest difference he sees is in timing.

This summer, clients who waited more than 24 hours to make an offer might find their

desired home had already been purchased.

"Now, it's a lot more of 'Remember that place you saw 10 days ago? Well, it's still there,

do you want to see it again?' " Mr. Jang says.

The slowdown could also affect speculative activity, as a slower rate of price growth

could make it more difficult to buy, renovate and sell homes for a fat return, Mr. Jang


But anybody hoping that prices may come back within reach for first-time buyers is

likely to be disappointed. Slowdown or no, Vancouver real estate remains too expensive

for many. A search for a single-family, detached home under $600,000 on Vancouver's

west side yields three listings, all on land leased from the Musqueam Indian Band. (A

fight over lease rates between leaseholders and the band in the 1990s led to a court case

and a plunge in market value for homes on band land.) A heritage home in Mount

Pleasant is listed at $799,000, despite having suffered a fire last year.

"Affordability is a big issue in Vancouver. And affordability is likely getting worse at a

[September] rate of increase of nearly 17 per cent. Because there's very little chance that

the income growth will grow at the same rate," says Craig Alexander, deputy chief

economist with TD Economics.

Mr. Alexander, who put Vancouver on a "housing bubble watch" in an August report,

says current trends show the market is responding to supply and demand, something he

sees as healthy. In a bubble scenario, prices keep climbing at the same rate even as supply

grows, he says.

He anticipates the rate of price increases will continue to slow.

"Twelve months from now, I would bet that home price growth in Vancouver would be

in the single digits. That's not a terrible outcome, that's a healthy income."

Rick Valouche, president of the Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver, says the market

is becoming more balanced. And this year's total sales are on track to surpass last year's

record total, he says.

Some buyers might be sitting on their hands as they assess whether wobbles in the U.S.

housing market will affect Vancouver, says Bob Rennie, whose Rennie Marketing

Systems sells Lower Mainland condominiums like proverbial hotcakes. U.S. housing

prices took their biggest drop in 35 years in September.

But after a few months, those buyers will be back in, Mr. Rennie predicts, driven by

factors that include the coming the 2010 Olympics, a shortage of land and the perception

of Vancouver as a safe place to invest.

Mr. Rennie is currently selling what he says is the most expensive real estate in Canada:

the Fairmont Pacific Estates on the downtown waterfront, where water-facing units are

going for about $2,000 a square foot and unit prices range from $1-million to $4.5-


His firm also recently sold 40 per cent of the units in a new Burnaby high-rise over a


"If that's slow, we'll take it all day long," he says.

Mr. Webber, who works in commercial real estate, is confident he'll sell his house, a

nearly new, three-bedroom detached townhouse in waterfront Steveston. And he doesn't

sound overly dismayed that he's had to drop the price from an original $679,000 to

$659,900, which is still well above what he paid three years ago. He says his home is in a

popular neighbourhood, "shows well" in real estate jargon and garners compliments from

everyone who walks in the door.

"Every weekend we seem to have someone through the open houses who is really

interested, who says 'you'll be hearing from us,' " says Mr. Webber, who's already

purchased a bigger home in another part of the city. "But nothing has happened."